Moths to a Flame: Millennia-Old Mystery About Insects and Light at Night Solved at Last

Scientists discovered that insects keep their backs to light sources at night, a behavior that suggests artificial lights disrupt their natural navigation. This finding, based on high-speed camera footage, challenges long-held beliefs and highlights the impact of artificial lighting on insect behavior and conservation.

At night in the Costa Rican cloud forest, a small team of international scientists switched on a light and waited. Soon, insects big and small descended out of the darkness. Moths with spots like unblinking eyes on each wing. Shiny armored beetles. Flies. Once, even a praying mantis. Each did the same hypnotic, dizzying dance around the bulb as if attached to it with invisible string.

Excitement spread through the group of researchers, even though this phenomenon was not new to them. The difference is they now have cutting-edge technology and high-speed cameras — capable of capturing the fast, frenzied orbits — to map the hard-to-track movements of hundreds of insects and tease out secrets surrounding why they act so strange around light at night.

The research project kicked off at Lin’s lab where Fabian works and has a motion capture arena like the kind used in movies — only insect-scale. Credit: Sam Fabian

Unveiling Insect Behavior

A surprising detail surfaced in the data: In flight, the insects kept their backs facing the artificial light source.

“You watch the videos in slow motion and see it happening again and again,” said Yash Sondhi, a recent FIU biological sciences Ph.D. graduate and current postdoctoral researcher at the Florida Museum of Natural History. “Maybe when people notice it, like around their porchlights or a streetlamp, it looks like they are flying straight at it, but that’s not the case.”

This never-before-documented behavior, published in the journal Nature Communications<em>Nature Communications</em> is a peer-reviewed, open-access, multidisciplinary, scientific journal published by Nature Portfolio. It covers the natural sciences, including physics, biology, chemistry, medicine, and earth sciences. It began publishing in 2010 and has editorial offices in London, Berlin, New York City, and Shanghai. ” data-gt-translate-attributes=”[{“attribute”:”data-cmtooltip”, “format”:”html”}]” tabindex=”0″ role=”link”>Nature Communications, provides a new explanation and while it confirms light is disruptive to insects, it also offers new insight into this conservation concern.

Little markers were affixed in an L-shape along the backs of several moths and dragonflies, so when they flew around light, they were also collecting data on how they rolled and rotated and moved through three-dimensional space. Credit: Sam Fabian

For millions of years, insects have evolved to become masters of flight by relying on the brightest thing they see — the sky. Today, the lit-up world throws their instincts for a loop. Insects think the imposter “sky” they find is the real one and get trapped in an exhausting cycle trying to stay orientated. It’s a futile effort that causes clumsy maneuvers and occasional crashes directly into the light.

[embedded content]

Gravity, Flight, and Artificial Light

A good grasp of gravity is mandatory for all animals.

Especially flying ones, like insects that perform feats of flight that can surpass those of human pilots. When flying, they experience such rapid acceleration that their gravity sensing becomes unreliable. They need the sky, even at night, to discern which way is up and cruise along, maintaining control in the air. Artificial light, however, messes with this system.

Sondhi started connecting the dots between insect vision, light, and flight when he joined FIU associate professor of biology Jamie Theobald’s lab in 2017.

The work really got off the ground, though, when he found a group of specialists in the fields of insect flight and sensory systems who were determined to collect and mull over a deluge of 3D flight data to see what, if anything, was revealed.

Insects flew in complex revolutions around an artificial light source, keeping their backs to the bulb, which they seem incapable of distinguishing from the night sky. Credit: Sam Fabian

Groundbreaking Discoveries and Future Considerations

That group included Sondhi and Theobald, as well as Sam Fabian and Huai-Ti Lin from the Imperial College LondonEstablished on July 8, 1907, by Royal Charter, Imperial College London is a public research university in London with a focus on science, engineering, medicine, and business. Its main campus is located in South Kensington, and it has an innovation campus in White City, a research field station at Silwood Park, and teaching hospitals throughout London. Its full legal name is the Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine.” data-gt-translate-attributes=”[{“attribute”:”data-cmtooltip”, “format”:”html”}]” tabindex=”0″ role=”link”>Imperial College London, and Pablo Allen from the Council on International Educational Exchange in Monteverde, Costa Rica.

The research project kicked off at Lin’s lab where Fabian works and has a motion capture arena like the kind used in movies — only insect-scale.

Credit: Florida Museum

Little markers were affixed in an L-shape along the backs of several moths and dragonflies, so when they flew around light, they were also collecting data on how they rolled and rotated and moved through three-dimensional space.

“On one of the very first experiments, I let a large yellow underwing moth take off from my hand and fly directly over UV bulb and it immediately flipped upside down,” he said. “But we didn’t know then if the behavior we saw and measured in the lab would also be seen in the wild.”

Attaching tracking devices to small insects required patience, dexterity and practice. Credit: Florida Museum photo by Jeff Gage

National Geographic funding helped the team travel to Costa Rica — a country rich with diverse insect life — with their cameras to find out.

In total, they collected more than 477 videos spanning more than 11 insect orders, and then used computer tools to reconstruct the points along 3D flight paths. Together with the motion capture data, the researchers concluded all the speciesA species is a group of living organisms that share a set of common characteristics and are able to breed and produce fertile offspring. The concept of a species is important in biology as it is used to classify and organize the diversity of life. There are different ways to define a species, but the most widely accepted one is the biological species concept, which defines a species as a group of organisms that can interbreed and produce viable offspring in nature. This definition is widely used in evolutionary biology and ecology to identify and classify living organisms.” data-gt-translate-attributes=”[{“attribute”:”data-cmtooltip”, “format”:”html”}]” tabindex=”0″ role=”link”>species did, in fact, flip upside down when exposed to light, just like the large yellow underwing in the lab.

To test their theory in the wild, the team traveled to the Estación Biológica Monteverde in Costa Rica, where they set up lights beneath the canopy of a tropical rainforest. Credit: Yash Sondhi

“This has been a prehistorical question. In the earliest writings, people were noticing this around fire,” Theobald said. “It turns out all our speculations about why it happens have been wrong, so this is definitely the coolest project I’ve been part of.”

While the study confirms light is disruptive to insects, it also suggests light direction matters. The worst is an upward-facing or just a bare bulb. Shrouding or shielding may be key to offsetting negative impacts to insects.

The type of light that’s most disruptive to insects comes from bulbs that are directed upward and those that lack a covering. Shrouding or shielding may be key to offsetting negative impacts to insects. Credit: Sam Fabian

The team is also thinking about light color, like if cool versus warm tones have different impacts. And, of course, the still unexplained mystery surrounding attraction to light — and how it happens in the first place over great distances.

“I’d been told before you can’t ask why questions like this one, that there was no point,” Sondhi said. “But in being persistent and finding the right people, we came up with an answer none of us really thought of, but that’s so important to increasing awareness about how light impacts insect populations and informing changes that can help them out.”

Reference: “Why flying insects gather at artificial light” by Samuel T. Fabian, Yash Sondhi, Pablo E. Allen, Jamie C. Theobald and Huai-Ti Lin, 30 January 2024, Nature Communications.
DOI: 10.1038/s41467-024-44785-3